Today 4

1916 Co. and WonderCare seal exclusive, Chubb-backed watch insurance

Bottom Line Impact

If executed with frictionless enrollment and strong SLAs, the partnership can add a high-margin service layer, lift retention 200-400 bps, and strengthen The 1916 Companys competitive moat while positioning WonderCare as a preferred insurtech for HNW watches.

Key Roles Affected

CEOCMOCOO/CTOCFO

Executive Summary

The 1916 Company has entered an exclusive partnership with WonderCare to offer streamlined luxury watch insurance underwritten by Chubb, the leading U.S. HNW personal lines carrier. This embeds a high-trust service into the client journey, creating a defensible differentiator, new fee revenue, and richer data for retention and upsell.

Actionable Insights

Immediate Actions (Next 30-90 days)
Set a 12-month attach-rate target of 20% for new and recent watch sales with quarterly milestones and P&L accountability.
Rationale: A clear KPI aligns sales, e-commerce, and clienteling around monetizing trust and improving lifetime value.
Role affected:CEO
Urgency level:immediate
Embed pre-filled quotes in checkout and clienteling apps via API; enable 1-click binding and digital certificate storage in the client vault.
Rationale: Frictionless enrollment can add 5-8 ppt to attach-rate while creating a service hub that increases engagement.
Role affected:COO/CTO
Urgency level:immediate
Short-term Actions (6-12 months)
Deploy co-branded Chubb x WonderCare messaging in post-purchase journeys and service reminders; A/B test pricing prompts and risk education.
Rationale: Trust cues from a #1 HNW insurer and education on loss risks materially lift conversion at key touchpoints.
Role affected:CMO
Urgency level:short-term
Negotiate revenue share on premiums and claims service fees; model unit economics to ensure contribution margin >10% after support costs.
Rationale: Insurance can be accretive if economics and claims admin costs are controlled; clear thresholds prevent dilution.
Role affected:CFO
Urgency level:short-term

Strategic Analysis

Next 30-90 days: integrate WonderCare flows into online and clienteling journeys; train advisors; launch targeted communications to recent buyers and high-risk locales; establish baseline attach-rate and SLAs with Chubb. Expect early attach-rate of 10-15% with concierge-assisted enrollment if messaging is embedded at evaluation and post-purchase checkpoints.

6-12 months: insurance becomes a retention and trust lever, lifting repeat purchase and trade-in rates; potential attach-rate scaling to 20-25% with pre-filled quotes and loyalty incentives. Data from insured values and models informs allocation and sourcing. Expansion path includes jewelry riders and selective international roll-out subject to licensing and underwriting appetite.

This differentiates The 1916 Company vs Watches of Switzerland and Bucherer by embedding a premium, HNW-trusted insurer. It narrows parity with Hodinkee-style offerings while moving insurance inside a retail ecosystem with service and trade-in capabilities. For WonderCare, landing an exclusive anchor boosts credibility and distribution, raising barriers for rival insurtechs and Jewelers Mutual-aligned programs.

Suppliers and brands benefit from reduced fraud and clearer provenance via insured inventories; logistics partners can bundle insured shipping; clients gain faster coverage and claims confidence; Chubb gains targeted HNW lead flow. Internal aftersales sees higher service plan uptake when paired with coverage, improving lifetime economics.

Risks & Opportunities

Primary Risks

  • Regulatory and licensing complexity could delay multi-state or international expansion and dilute exclusivity benefits
  • Claims experience spikes or denial controversies could trigger reputational damage with HNW clients
  • Operational friction if advisor tools and APIs are not stable, reducing attach-rate and client satisfaction

Primary Opportunities

  • Increased retention and trade-in velocity from insured clients, improving lifetime value and inventory circulation
  • Cross-sell of service plans, authentication, and insured shipping to create a comprehensive protection bundle
  • Data-driven allocation and sourcing using insured value signals to optimize high-demand SKUs

Market Context

Embedded finance is gaining traction in luxury as brands seek non-discretionary value adds amid softer watch demand and China uncertainty; U.S. HNW clients remain resilient but more risk-aware. Competitors like Bucherer and Watches of Switzerland emphasize clienteling and services, while platforms such as Hodinkee previously partnered with insurers; an exclusive, Chubb-backed integration inside a retail-led ecosystem raises the bar on trust. Gen-Z and younger HNW entrants value convenience and protection, making embedded insurance a credible differentiator when paired with authenticated resale and aftersales.

Back to The 1916 Company All Companies